The character of Papa (Eugene) is an example of what can
happen when a person uses religion to justify their actions throughout life. He
is an older Catholic man, living in post-colonial Nigeria, most likely in his
50s, with a possibly younger wife who is attempting to conceive a child in
order to hold her family and position in society together. His most interesting
relationship is with his daughter, Kambili. She is unable to see what the
reader sees. She looks up at Papa with both admiration and fear even though he
abuses the family. He beats each member of the family and psychologically
torments them. Kambili’s consistent attempts to please him in every aspect of
life showcases the behavior of someone who is abused and struggling to please
their abuser. Every semester she tries to be first in her class of 25. When she
comes in an impressive second one semester, he subjects her to psychological
punishment. However, Papa shows more affection for Kambili than he does anyone
else in the book. Papa is not only a tyrannical figure in his household, but
also in the religious community as well. He controls many of the actions that
occur with the priest and other aspects of the Church. When Kambili goes in for
a confessional one day, it can be noted that it appears as if the Priest
already knows what she has done. This is concerning because what should be
considered a very private, therapeutic event for Kambili is in actuality
another attempt from her father to psychologically manipulate her. He does care
for his family, but he has no compassion and a warped sense of morality. He
wants his family members to succeed not simply for them, but for himself.
If I had to compare him to one character in the short
stories we have read it would be Shakumar in a Temporary Matter. Papa and
Shakumar parallel each other in a couple of ways. Papa is oblivious to the
seriousness of the problems in his families relationships, while Shakumar can
also be described in the same way. They both don’t realize what their lack of
affection towards their family members has done until it is too late. In many
ways, Shobha, the wife in a Temporary Matter is also similar to Beatrice,
Papa’s wife. Both suffer from a miscarriage and struggle with the aftermath
while living in unsatisfying marriages. They also feel as if they are less of a
woman because they are unable to carry those children to term.
Wow yeah good character comparison. I wouldn't have thought of that but I definitely see it now. Good job writing about Papa as a dynamic and human character without eliciting sympathy for him - i think that is the most productive way to discuss him.
ReplyDeleteThis is all very well put. Papa's character, in my opinion, is a truly terrible man. I couldn't say if my opinion is justified or not, though, because I feel like it's extremely possible that most father figures in such wealthy families are that way in Nigeria. Lots of good points.
ReplyDeleteThat's a really interesting comparison; I never would have thought two relate those two characters. I also completely agree with your insight into the relationship between Kambili and her father. It is completely obvious to the reader that he is psychologically manipulating and abusing her for his own purposes of having, what he thinks, is a perfect, god-fearing family, but Kambili doesn't see this at all. It may be that she feels like she has to please him because he's her father, and the potential punishment is far worse than anything she would otherwise have to do. And I didn't even realize this before you mentioned it, but the confessional part completely shows how manipulative the father is because he turns something personal into his own way of gaining information.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with your post. I'm glad that you noted that "She is unable to see what the reader sees." A lot of readers get frustrated with characters like Kambili, who relentlessly look up to the most tyrannical character without reason. It's important to realize that she is unable to see what we see. Nice job!
ReplyDelete